I grew this one when it was new. I gave it to my best friend's father, if I recall correctly. It wasn't too big, kind of chunky growth, and mostly healthy. The problem was that it was not gold, and the pictures here are generous. It was a pastel yellow for the most part, going into white. The other problem was its growth. I gifted him roses like Livin' Easy, H.C. Anderson, Sunsprite, and so on. So while it fit the height requirement, it looked off.