|
|
'Madame Joseph Perraud' rose Reviews & Comments
-
-
|
this file for Mme. Joseph Perraud contains two yellow pictures of 'Sunburst'.
............ Patricia Routley
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#1 of 7 posted
10 JUL 07 by
 Cass
|
Hi, Patricia,
Modern Roses has shown 'Sunburst' as a synonym for 'Mme. Joseph Perraud' since Modern Roses 6 in 1965. Before that, 'Sunburst' wasn't mentioned.
Whether either the tangerine or all-yellow blooms are 'Mme. Joseph Perraud' is a different and legitimate question.
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#2 of 7 posted
10 JUL 07 by
jedmar
|
Cass, I think the yellow Sunburst photos belong to Sunburst of Pernet-Ducher. The description of Mme Joseph Perraud should be changed to an orange-blend. Modern Roses is misleading. See the references from Rosenlexikon and Rosenverzeichnis.
|
REPLY
|
|
Hi Patricia; Do you know if this rose is available here in OZ.
cheers Warren
|
REPLY
|
|
No, I don't Warren. David Ruston was listing a 1934 "yellow blend" HT from Gaujard in his 2003-2004 catalogue. I would see if you can get budwood from there.
In 2006, during a post conference tour here, someone came running to me to say I had 'Mme. Joseph Perraud'. There was no time just then to query which foundling of mine it might be. Later I tried to find out and unless this pictured one was it, I have no idea if I have it or not. By now the foundling is not a very healthy rose.
|
REPLY
|
|
Warren, did you ever manage to get 'Mme. Joseph Perraud'.
|
REPLY
|
|
After one plant (pictured above in comment 4) of my foundling "Birte Venske No. 4" dying, and the other looking very sick for a few years, I moved the remaining plant back to a pot where it recovered nicely. I have recently planted it out and because of someone's (David's, Phillip's or Greg's?) 2006 thought that it was 'Mme. Joseph Perraud' 1934, and photos uploaded by others since then, I rather think it might be. My only other thought at one time was that it may be 'Hinrich Gaede' 1931. I'll upload some photos.
|
REPLY
|
|
