HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
Search PostsPosts By CategoryRecent Posts 
Questions, Answers and Comments by Category
Discussion id : 2-109
most recent 23 MAY 06 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 4 JUN 03 by Anonymous-797
How to prevent deer from eating roses and buds?
REPLY
Reply #1 of 11 posted 4 JUN 03 by Unregistered Guest
I have never tried this personally but have been told that if you border the area with human hair trimmings the smell well keep the deer away. I am very soon going to start a rose garden where there are many deer day and night. I will try this myself as it was "sworn to work."
REPLY
Reply #2 of 11 posted 21 SEP 03 by Nicole
Deer LOVE eating roses! Nothing will stop them .....unless they can't get to them. Enclose each rose bush with chicken wire,even the top! This is the only prevention from deer.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 11 posted 22 DEC 04 by Lydia
I, too, live in deer country and have had some success with a product called Plant Skyd. It is expensive and smells AWFUL when it is applied. The smell does fade after a few hours. Don't stand downwind when you apply it, however.
REPLY
Reply #4 of 11 posted 21 FEB 05 by anonymous-19481
I live in the Pacific Northwest and was told that a mixture of egg, chili powder and water sprayed on roses somewhat regularly will help control the deer. It has worked for me!
REPLY
Reply #5 of 11 posted 22 FEB 05 by RoseBlush
Believe it or not, there are whole books written about this subject ! That's why I smiled when I saw your question about deer candy...ooops... rose buds. I have just moved into deer country and have learned several things from the books. One of the less intrusive methods is to plant deer-resistant plants as part of a border around the garden and in with the roses. Plants like rosemary, sage, lavender and a lot more.

The theory is that the scent of these plants destroys the deer's ability to smell and they believe they are in danger of being eaten by predators and avoid this type of garden. Makes sense to me and I do know some people who have had success with designing their gardens in this fashion.

Does it always work? No. Deer can't read books. However, I like these plants and am including them in my garden.

This last year, I put chicken wire flat on the soil under the mulch and planted underplantings that grew up through the wire. It worked this year. Who knows? Next year another deer might not mind stepping on the wire.

However, the library and the net provides a lot of information on this subject.

Smiles,

Lyn
helpmefind.com
REPLY
Reply #6 of 11 posted 23 MAY 05 by jane
i have used this spray for the last five years on the gardens that i maintain, and it works .. 1 quart of water in a blender .. add 1 egg yolk (no white) and 1 tablespoon of baking powder .. gently blend, put into some kind of sprayer, and spray directly on any plants that deer have eaten in the past .. you need to apply this every 2-3 weeks, regardless of rain .. or, in the event that thoughts of deer come to mind, spray that day! .. good luck .. i'm sure you'll see things bloomed that never had a chance before because they'd been nipped ..
REPLY
Reply #7 of 11 posted 29 AUG 05 by Unregistered Guest
I live in New Jersey and we have a large deer problem, they are in my yard almost every night and destroy everything. We've tried may different things including cyote pee and a number of concoctions. One of the big problems is trying to tell if something is being effective. Recently i did an Internet search on the problem and found a number of people recomending "Deer Out" and decided to give it a try. I don't have too many things in bloom right now but one was a gemini rose so I sprayed the top buds and blooms with Deer Out. Recently i was looking at the plant and realized that the deer had eaten all the leaves off the plant up to the point where i had sprayed it. The top leaves and blooms were left intact. This is the first real evidence that i have seen of a product stopping the destruction. Oh and the best thing about the product is that it smells like mint, not vomit or rotten eggs.
REPLY
Reply #8 of 11 posted 30 AUG 05 by Wendy C
A friend of mine has been using a pepper spray on her daylilies w/success. Lyn is very correct there are a million different methods. Deer are adaptors.

Deer pop over our five foot fence as if it wasn't there. Our dogs (artic breeds) sleep outside and they are most efficient in keeping the deer at bay. As attentive as the dogs are the deer still manage to nibble on the first shoots of my daylilies every Spring.

Good luck
REPLY
Reply #9 of 11 posted 12 APR 06 by Anonymous-797
Deer Off works really well.  Works for weeks.  I don't believe the human hair thing or predator pee.   Our black lab does a good job of covering the perimeter (if you know what I mean) but the deer don't care.  Planting poisonous and deer-repellent plants doesn't work either.  I have quite a bit of lavender, sage and rosemary and haven't noticed any deterrent effect.  But it's possible that the deer here are more aggressive.
I think the main ingredients in Deer Off are garlic and egg.  I'm going to start mixing my own when my current bottle runs out. 

One thing that did seem to work to keep them away from some baby roses was to string monofilament line in an "invisible" fence.  I used bamboo stakes and created a fence around the roses.  Apparently the deer don't like the fact that they can feel the lines but can't see them.  It seemed to work.  Of course the roses in question are rugosas so they aren't as attractive to deer at any rate.  Your mileage may vary but it's worth a try!
REPLY
Reply #10 of 11 posted 13 APR 06 by RoseBlush

Hi.


You are correct not all methods work in every local.  We have  semi-serious mountain lion problem up here and our deer are very wary of preditors.  Also I think the deer-deterant plants need to be planted in the path that the deer normally follow. (Deer know which plants are poisoness, so no need to bother with those).  When I first moved here, I saw deer in the front of my property as well as on the upper slope of the back of my property.  My deer fence has taken care of the back part, so I can plant roses safely back there.  Now that the deer deterant plants have gotten larger, the deer have stopped coming into my front yard, too.  Of course, there is a large park across the street and they would rather go down there because it seems safer.


 


Smiles,


Lyn....helpmefind.com

REPLY
Reply #11 of 11 posted 23 MAY 06 by Simon Taylor
Try attaching  unwanted CDs on canes with string so they move in the breeze
REPLY
© 2025 HelpMeFind.com