|
'Aromatherapy ™' rose Reviews & Comments
-
-
Initial post
11 OCT 07 by
Unregistered Guest
I agree. I'm about to pull it. It has no scent, I don't care what they named it. This rose by any other name would have no scent.
|
REPLY
|
Funny a vase full of them in my living room fills the entire room with fragrance.
|
REPLY
|
Is your nose working correctly???
|
REPLY
|
Hi! Just out of curiosity, have you ever had your genes sequenced? For example, by 23AndMe.com? If you have, you can run it through the Promethase engine (https://promethease.com/ondemandlicense) and it will tell you if you have a genetic variant that disallows you to smell β-ionone, a floral fragrance. I have this variation (in rs6591536, also known as N183D or Asn183Asp) and a lot of the roses that some people say are very fragrant, such as JFK, smell like plain old florist roses to me. On the other hand, I can still enjoy roses like Chrysler Imperial, Mr. Lincoln, Angel Face, and Julia Child.
It would be very interesting to me if this is the case, you might have just saved me from spending a lot of money on a rose I can't smell.
|
REPLY
|
Mine is definitely highly fragrant. Even in raining 55F weather, it is.
|
REPLY
|
-
-
I was pretty startled to see people rate Aromatherapy as not being fragrant. It has a real nice fragrance in my organics garden, and it has a nice quantity of blooms when it does flush. Aromatherapy has the rebloom factor of a typical HT --4 weeks resting period in my heavy clay soil/climate conditions. The really bad part about Aromatherapy is that it is a sheer disaster in an all-organics garden in terms of BS resistance. I wlll coddle highly fragrant roses so I am keeping it until I find a highly fragrant pink rose that stays pink (without fading to white) in blasting Midwestern sun. Aromatherapy's bubble gum pink is absolutely perfect in my garden scheme, and I want a rose that stays this way. Note, I don't think Aromatherapy is normally a large-flowered rose unless people are artificially pumping it with Miracle Gro???? It is actually a medium-sized bloom. To me I consider "large" like a Pope John HT or Lincoln or an Austin something of that nature.
|
REPLY
|
-
-
Initial post
15 MAR 11 by
monica
I purchase aromatherapy as a fall rose from J&P 2 seasons ago. The first season it didnt do much seeing as it was very small. Last season it began to grow but i didnt get much bloom on the plant,i believe it because i have a mole,vole and shrew problem. Last fall we decided to rock all of my flower beds to prevent the moles/shrew from enjoying the roots of my roses. I noticed a big difference in the roses. Aromatherapy did indeed bloom, it was a beautiful large rose and it had a very strong scent. Hopefully this season will be better for the roses as they will not have to recovery from being eaten. Aromatherapy is hardy to zone 6 winters, with very little dieback. I didnot protect it with mulch this winter because of the rocks,but i guess that was enough because aromatherapy looks just fine. This plant has an upright growth habit. I will update its progress through the summer.
|
REPLY
|
-
-
"The present invention relates to a new and distinct variety of a hybrid tea rose plant named `JAChonew` which was originated by me by crossing an unnamed, unpatented pink hybrid seedling, (`JAColite` (U.S. Plant Pat. No. 4,167).times.`KORlingo` (U.S. Plant Pat. No. 5,846)) with the variety `MACgenev` (U.S. Plant Pat. No. 8,279). "
|
REPLY
|
Reply
#1 of 2 posted
2 NOV 07 by
Cass
Still not nearly as good a rose as STEbigpu
|
REPLY
|
|